BOOK REVIEW

Book Review

Life's Matrix
A Biography of Water

[review] [excerpt] [endlinks] [purchase]

by Philip Ball

Reviewed by Ed Voves

Farrar, Strauss & Giroux, 2000

Posted December 8, 2000 · Issue 92


Review

The color of planet Earth, when viewed from an orbiting spacecraft, is largely the color of water. The dark blue of the oceans predominates, accentuated by the swirling gray of clouds and mist and the stark white of the polar ice caps.

Water creates an "oasis in space."

Water is naturally colorless. But the spectacle of the glistening planet, with over two-thirds of its surface area covered by liquid water, created a lasting impression when first photographed in the 1960s. Set against a background of infinite blackness, Earth indeed seems to be an oasis in space.

"We call our home Earth," writes Philip Ball, "but Water would be more apt." In his new book Life's Matrix, Ball aims to promote greater awareness of, and insight into, the complex, baffling liquid from which all life flows.

Ball conveys boundless curiosity, vast knowledge, and a sense of humor.

Ball is a writer and consulting editor for the British journal Nature. He approaches the study of water in its varied forms with a blend of boundless curiosity and a literary style enriched by vast knowledge of the subject and a sense of humor. He focuses upon his subject with determined professional scrutiny as well, especially in his discussion of the scientific community's occasional lapses into delusion with such ill-conceived projects as research into polywater and cold fusion.

Life's Matrix is a book of ambitious scope, covering an amazing range of themes and topics. The intricate bonding of water molecules; the perplexing nature of supercooled water; the existence of water as ice or vapor on the moon and other planets; the transforming effect of water on Earth's weather and atmosphere; its role in the physiology of plants and animals; and its utilization, for good or ill, by human societies are all surveyed in this remarkable synthesis of scientific knowledge.

The author begins his study at the beginning of beginnings - the Big Bang. He shows how hydrogen and oxygen were formed and then united "within the imponderable expanses of interstellar space . . . and there in the making is the river Nile, the Arabian Sea, the clouds and the snowflakes, the juice of cells, the ice plains of Neptune, and who knows what other rivers, oceans and raindrops on worlds we may never see."

The study of water is a slippery business.

Although a water molecule is a simple bond of two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom, the study of water is a vastly complex, slippery business. Computer simulations are only beginning to reveal the manner in which water molecules bond. At almost every level of every scientific discipline concerned with the substance, the "weirdness" of water confounds and excites the search for understanding.

An especially noteworthy example of water's paradoxical nature occurs in Ball's discussion of ocean currents. A vast global conveyor system circulates water from the Pacific Ocean to the North Atlantic and back again, based upon differences in water temperature and the levels of salt dissolved in the seawater. Warm water flows from the Pacific close to the surface and then, cooled in the Atlantic and heavy with salt, it drops to the depths of the ocean, reverses course, skirting Antarctica, and flows back into the Pacific.

The Younger Dryas played havoc with ocean temperatures.

This process plays an important role in moderating the climate of the planet. Yet, about 10,500 years ago, as climatic conditions were warming at the end of the most recent ice age, there was a sudden shift back to frigid, glacial conditions. What happened? Scientists now believe that this plunge in temperatures, known as the Younger Dryas event, occurred when the Pacific-Atlantic circulation was impeded by a massive inflow of meltwater from the thawing northern ice sheets. This played havoc with ocean temperatures, triggering a renewed surge of icy cold weather conditions.

The implications of this sudden reversion are ominous, given the growing fears about global warming. Could melting polar ice presage a man-made ice age? Would coastal cities endure a deep freeze rather than being menaced by a rise in ocean levels?

The growing lack of fresh water is a pressing concern.

A related concern involves the effectiveness of scientific research in curing the world's water-related ills. The growing shortage of freshwater is of even more pressing concern than global warming. Indeed, given the explosive rate of population growth and widespread pollution of water sources, this is not a matter of future speculation, but a present reality.

The record of scientific research into the nature of water itself hardly inspires confidence. Ball examines, at considerable length, the embarrassing polywater episode of the 1960s and the equally illusory plan in 1989 to produce power from electrolyzed heavy water through cold fusion.

Polywater research inflated.

In the first incident, Russian scientists believed that they had found a way to produce a new form of high-density water. Researchers in Britain and the United States attempted to confirm the result. When word of the tests leaked to the press, wildly inflated claims of future uses of polywater were made, including some by scientists who should have known better.

These great expectations were to be sorely disappointing. Only minute quantities of polywater were ever produced. Eventually, research showed that this substance was the result of contamination during the experimentation process. Serious inquiry into the nature of water suffered from a rush to unfounded conclusions in this and similar scientific misadventures. But, in such scientific missteps, a great deal more than injured reputations is at stake.

Life's Matrix is of profound value.

As Ball shows in his concluding chapter, the planet's water resources are increasingly at risk. Scientific research has made major advances in countering some of the environmental hazards, as in the recent reduction of acid rain in Europe. But there are always limits - imposed by cost, social factors, and national rivalries - as to what can be achieved.

There are no simple answers. But as Ball perceptively notes, water-related issues are gradually consolidating into one overarching question. Who owns water? Is it a communal resource governed by ethical considerations? Or is it a commodity determined by wealth and the power of nation-states?

Life's Matrix is a notable first step toward addressing these crucial concerns. Philip Ball has written a book of profound value, filling many of the gaps in our evolving understanding of water and our appreciation of its vital role in the life of the planet ironically known as Earth.

Ed Voves is a news researcher for Philadelphia Newspapers Inc., publishers of the Philadelphia Inquirer and Daily News. For the past twelve years, he has written book reviews, author interviews, and other news articles for both papers.

Excerpt

What is so special about the Earth . . . is not that it is a world of water, but that the water is marine blue - we have oceans, not just glassy sheets of ice. Perhaps, soon after the solar system was formed, blue worlds were commonplace, until one by one they turned pearly or ruddy, or became shrouded in bright acid. And then there we were, a lone blue dot, waiting for life to begin.


You may purchase this book (400 pp., hardcover) directly from:



Tell us what you think.
FeedbackFeedback

Do you want your book reviewed by HMS Beagle?


Endlinks

H2O - The Mystery, Art & Science of Water - Sweet Briar College provides class notes from a "multidisciplinary examination of the nature, properties, place, significance, importance, and role of water in the life and culture of this planet."

Environment Canada: Freshwater Web Site - explores the molecular composition of water, the hydrologic cycle, water supply management, legislative issues, and the cultural significance of water.

Water World - a gateway site hosted by Ohio State University. It provides easy access to a host of water-related Web sites, including government, academic, and industry sites.

The Great Climate Flip-Flop - offers a brilliant discussion of the abrupt climate change involving the ocean currents known as the Younger Dryas event. From the January 1998 issue of the Atlantic Monthly.

Oceans Alive! The Water Planet - describes the formation of Earth's oceans from the period before continental drift and recounts exploration by scientists using the most modern techniques of oceanography.

Hydrologic Cycle: Online Meteorology Guide - provides a look at the meteorological role of water, using animated charts and readily understandable text. Presented by the University of Illinois.

Ice on the Moon - a NASA Web page detailing the 1998 detection of ice on the lunar surface. It includes a discussion of its significance for the study of the formation of the solar system and possible uses by a space station crew on the moon.


Previous Book Reviews

Who Wrote the Book of Life? A History of the Genetic Code
by Lily E. Kay; reviewed by Alan I. Packer
(Posted November 24, 2000 · Issue 91)
Biotechnology Is Murder
by Dirk Wyle; reviewed by Charles Ouimet
(Posted November 10, 2000 · Issue 90)
Guide to Nontraditional Careers in Science
by Karen Young Kreeger; reviewed by Peter S. Fiske
(Posted October 27, 2000 · Issue 89)
Great Minds of Science
Hosted by Paul Hoffman; reviewed by Dean A. Haycock
(Posted October 13, 2000 · Issue 88)
The Monk in the Garden: The Lost and Found Genius of Gregor Mendel
by Robin Marantz Henig; reviewed by Jim Dawson
(Posted September 29, 2000 · Issue 87)
A Gathering of Wonders: Behind the Scenes at the American Museum
of Natural History
by Joseph Wallace; reviewed by Alan I. Packer
(Posted September 15, 2000 · Issue 86)

more