DEBATE

Life: What Exactly Is It?

A Site Map
of the Debate


(Posted June 25, 1999 · Issue 57)



Debate Documents
 A Synopsis of the Debate,
 by moderator M. Ran
 Page 1: Stanley L. Miller
 Page 2: Antonio Lazcano
 Page 3: Mark Bedau
 Page 4: Thomas Ray
 Page 5: Claire Fraser
 Participants
 Feedback
 Internet sites relating to the debate
 How to cite the debate


Editor's Note

What is life, and how is it defined? While there have been tremendous advances in both technological possibilities and knowledge concerning our understanding of life, the actual working definition of life has not changed substantially for many years. What has changed is where the boundaries lie, and how far each advance in the quest to unravel the ultimate question of life pushes those boundaries.

Is all life carbon-based and self-replicating? If so, where does that leave mules, or the elderly? How do the modern advances in cloning, and test-tube life, as well as "living" computers, enter into the equation? What occurs between apparently "nonliving" compounds, the so-called building blocks of life, that gave rise to the spark of life on this planet?

A fascinating puzzle and perhaps one of the oldest questions in science - what exactly is life?

Andrzej Krauze is an illustrator, poster maker, cartoonist, and painter who illustrates regularly for HMS Beagle, The Guardian, The Sunday Telegraph, Bookseller, and New Statesman.

Previous Cutting Edge Debates
Consciousness
(Posted May 14, 1999 · Issue 54)
Alternative Medicine
(Posted March 5, 1999 · Issue 49)
The Future of Medical Publishing
(Posted January 22, 1999 · Issue 46)
Gene Therapy
(Posted October 16, 1998 · Issue 40)
Cannibalism
(Posted August 7, 1998 · Issue 36)
Science Funding
moderated by Donna Crane (Posted June 26, 1998  ·   Issue 33)
Medical Use of Marijuana
moderated by Rik Musty (Posted May 15, 1998  ·   Issue 30)
Career Changes in Science
moderated by Amy Fluet (Posted March 23, 1998  ·   Issue 27)
Model Systems
moderated by Jessica Bolker (Posted January 30, 1998  ·   Issue 24)
Neurodegenerative Diseases
moderated by Donald Price (Posted December 5, 1997  ·   Issue 21)
Shedding Light on Melatonin
moderated by Larry Morin (Posted October 17, 1997  ·   Issue 18)
The Origin of Life
moderated by Michael Meyer (Posted September 5, 1997  ·   Issue 15)
Optimum Mutation Rates in Evolution and Disease
moderated by Bryn Bridges (Posted July 25, 1997  ·   Issue 13)
Models of Immunologic Tolerance
moderated by Kenneth F. Schaffner (Posted June 27, 1997  ·   Issue 11)
Science and Ethics of Mammalian Cloning
moderated by Jon Gordon (Posted May 16, 1997  ·   Issue 8)
Making Sense of Antisense
moderated by C.A. Stein (Posted April 23, 1997  ·   Issue 6)
Academic Tenure: Is It Necessary?
moderated by William Tucker (Posted March 5, 1997  ·   Issue 4)
Do Orphan Receptors Have Ligands?
moderated by Mitch Lazar (Posted February 20, 1997   ·   Issue 2)
The Origin and Evolution of Introns
moderated by Russ Doolittle (Posted February 1, 1997  ·   Issue 1)