BOOK REVIEW

bookcover Blood
An Epic History of Medicine and Commerce
[review] [excerpt] [endlinks] [purchase]

by Douglas Starr
Knopf, 1998

Reviewed by Ed Voves

(Posted January 8, 1999 · Issue 45)

Review

Of all the symbols of human life, blood may best exemplify the enduring dualism of good and evil: innocent blood and bad blood, blood pure and blood defiled, blood sacrificed in noble endeavor and blood shed in vain. The full spectrum of human nobility and villainy seems to reside in the blood. And as Douglas Starr recounts in his provocative, superbly crafted new book Blood: An Epic History of Medicine and Commerce, there is money in the life-sustaining bodily fluid as well. While never forgetting its biological function, Starr chronicles human blood as a source of profitable pharmaceutical products - plasma, albumin, clotting factor for patients with hemophilia - and as an item of commerce.

The intertwined relationship of blood and money developed as the practice of Western medicine became more scientific, especially during the 20th century. Like so many efforts to better the human condition, the story of blood research and development is a tale of tragedy as well as triumph. Blood is a gripping, fast-paced medical thriller with protagonists drawn from real life. Starr's journalistic background - he is a former newspaper reporter and science editor for the PBS series Bodywatch and currently teaches and coordinates the graduate Program in Science Journalism at Boston University - is of prime importance. His deft handling of plot and character impart a feeling of "you are there" immediacy to his narrative. His set-piece episodes, such as the World War II development of blood plasma, are skillfully woven into the broad scheme of medical and social trends.

There are many heroes in the story of how blood evolved from a mystical substance to a mainstay of the health sciences. Yet there is no one figure, no dominant individual like Louis Pasteur or Jonas Salk who can be placed on a pedestal and proclaimed the discoverer of blood. Instead, the protagonists of Starr's account represent the progressive, incremental course of modern scientific discovery.

Blood is a body product rather than a healing substance drawn from nature or discovered in a laboratory. But the process that has transformed blood into "nearly a score of injectable substances" capable of "saving lives all over the world" is largely unfamiliar territory, especially for the general public. Blood plasma, for instance, saved hundreds of thousands of lives during World War II, but does not figure as prominently in historical texts as magic bullets like penicillin.

Starr begins his story in characteristically dramatic style with the 1667 experiment by French physician Jean-Baptist Denis, who transfused 10 ounces of calf's blood into the veins of an emotionally disturbed patient. The experiment was a radical departure from contemporary practice, given the universal belief that bleeding was the proper course of action to relieve an imbalance of bodily humors. In another sense, Denis acted in accordance with the ancient belief known as "vitalism," whereby the essence of an animal's characteristics - in this case a calf's tranquillity - could be transfused into an ailing human.

Regardless of whether Denis was a visionary or a quack, his experiment ended in the death of his patient. Attempts to transfuse human blood during the 19th century showed more promise, but primitive equipment and a lack of real knowledge into the composition of blood resulted in many fatalities. Karl Landsteiner's discovery of blood types in 1900 and the development of anticoagulants by Richard Lewisohn were the crucial steps toward the establishment of safe transfusion and blood banks.

The escalating demand for blood created by the huge casualties of World War II led to the next major development - and to bureaucratic wrangling as well. Because of the delicate nature of whole blood, the U.S. launched a massive effort, orchestrated by Edwin Cohn of Harvard University, to produce blood products such as dried plasma. This was a major breakthrough because it allowed plasma to be taken directly into the battle zone. But it was soon discovered that exclusive use of plasma deprived the bloodstream of needed oxygen. When the U.S. Army surgeon general still balked over sending whole blood to the front, surgeons initially had to rely on blood donated by the troops.

Like oil, blood was refined into new and useful products during the war. When peacetime came, however, the refining process continued but the patriotic zeal to donate blood did not. To maintain supply and profits, blood banks had to develop new strategies, such as tapping the blood of the poor in the U.S. and Latin America, as well as that of prison convicts and alcoholics.

By the time the AIDS crisis struck in the early 1980s, the blood-products industry was already in crisis. Use was skyrocketing as the factor VIII clotting formula was hailed as a salvation in the treatment of hemophilia. Unfortunately, contamination of the blood supply by hepatitis-infected donors was rising, too. This should have sounded alarm bells with the emerging threat of HIV/AIDS. As Starr reveals, the alarm did sound, but it was ignored by many medical authorities around the world. The continued use of AIDS-contaminated blood supplies after the danger was recognized completes this sad and sinister chapter in medical history. The imperatives of profit-seeking, largely as a result of national policy agendas, clouded the decisions of medical authorities in the U.S., France, Japan, and elsewhere. Starr deals cogently and with a measure of restrained passion in recounting the erosion of ethical standards during the AIDS crisis. But the subject does not make for easy reading.

Blood fills a gap in the history of medicine by stressing the importance of transfusion and its pioneers. Of equal importance, Starr's book is a powerful warning of what can occur when blood is typed in terms of dollars, yen, or pounds sterling rather than as A, B, AB, or O.

Ed Voves is a news researcher for Philadelphia Newspapers Inc., publishers of the Philadelphia Inquirer and the Philadelphia Daily News. For the past 12 years, he has written book reviews, author interviews, and other news articles for both papers.

Excerpt
Yet, if blood from another was a gift, there was no denying it was also a commodity and embodied the contradictions of both. "Give the gift of life," the Red Cross would implore, and as people did so the organization made money. Mothers had infused the gift of life into their sons, but found they had injected sickness instead. So much had been promised; no wonder the blood scandals that erupted around the world resounded so loudly with cries of broken faith and betrayal.

Tell us about your favorite books.

Endlinks

A Brief History of HIV/AIDS - a timeline that includes events covered in Blood. Presented by AEGIS, the AIDS/HIV database.

Blood Plasma Derivatives and Biotechnology's Contribution - a useful summary of blood plasma fractionation, the blood products derived from it, and the role of biotechnology. A short analysis of risks and problems attached to plasma production is included. From the Toronto Biotechnology Initiative.

Facts About Blood - information on blood and its components, the dangers posed by diseases like hepatitis and AIDS, and the history of blood transfusion from the American Association of Blood Banks.

Hematology - a long list of blood-related Web links that includes scholarly journals, sites dealing with specific diseases, and medical centers and foundations. From MedMark.

The Heart: An Online Exploration - a well-designed site from the Franklin Institute in Philadelphia that provides a good introduction to the study of blood.

Genes and Blood Type - an introduction for a general audience.


You may purchase this book (448 pp., hardcover) directly from:

  • Or purchase from another recommended location listed on our Web Bookstores page.


    Previous Beagle Book Reviews
    Holiday Reading: Browsing for the Big Picture
    by Dean A. Haycock
    (Posted December 11, 1998 · Issue 44)
    The Trembling Mountain: A Personal Account of Kuru,
    Cannibals, and Mad Cow Disease
    by Robert Klitzman; reviewed by Jeanine Barone
    (Posted November 27, 1998 · Issue 43)
    The Nurture Assumption: Why Children Turn Out the
    Way They Do
    by Judith Rich Harris; reviewed by John W. Murray
    (Posted November 13, 1998 · Issue 42)
    Toward a Democratic Science: Scientific Narration and
    Civic Communication
    by Richard Harvey Brown; reviewed by Jim Dawson
    (Posted October 30, 1998 · Issue 41)
    At the Bench: A Laboratory Navigator
    by Kathy Barker; reviewed by Alan I. Packe
    (Posted October 16, 1998 · Issue 40)
    Great Feuds in Science: Ten of the Liveliest Disputes Ever
    by Hal Hellman; reviewed by Tim Tokaryk
    (Posted October 2, 1998 · Issue 39)

    more