CUTTING EDGE
Gene Therapy
A Site Map
of the Debate

(Updated November 13, 1998 · Issue 42)

Debate Documents
The Issue

The U.S. genome project hurtles toward its postmillennial conclusion. Our human genome has been mapped and mapped again, and so have the genomes of worms and bacteria, livestock and pet dogs. This is very exciting - except for those families affected by genetic disease. They continue to wait for solutions that will save loved ones from a lifetime of suffering or an early death - the consequences of an undesirable mutation.

To date, progress toward effective gene therapy has been much less spectacular than the news reports of genetic advances seem to promise. A few children with the very rare hereditary immune disorder called adenosine deaminase deficiency appear to have been successfully treated with their own altered blood cells. Young people with cystic fibrosis - the most common single-gene hereditary disorder among Caucasians - yearn for the day when research finally reveals the best way to deliver the genetic information that could cure them. Progress toward effective gene therapy is tantalizing, but to those with genetic disease, the answer seems always to recede toward the horizon.

Meanwhile, the gene hunters are continually finding new molecular clues to disease. We are learning the genome. How close are we, really, to fixing its flaws? Fixing them how? What should we fix first - and are there flaws we should never try to fix?

To address these questions, HMS Beagle assembled a panel of eminent researchers in the field, and added two participants with an unusual perspective: A physician who has conducted research and written about ethical issues in genetics, and a theologian who has published articles and books about biotechnology. Together they address not only the technical hurdles that lie ahead, but the moral challenges as well.

Our Sponsor

Nature Genetics, the leading international research journal in genetics, is now available in full text online. With a new impact factor of 38.854, Nature Genetics is the world's foremost source of information for geneticists. Now all personal subscribers to the print edition also enjoy free access to the full-text Web site. Don't miss out any longer: start your personal subscription and get free access to Nature Genetics full text online and immediate desktop access, sophisticated searching, articles that can be printed in HTML or PDF formats, plus extra Web features and articles. Visit the Web site for details.

Andrzej Krauze is an illustrator, poster maker, cartoonist, and painter who illustrates regularly for HMS Beagle, The Guardian, The Sunday Telegraph, Bookseller, and New Statesman.

Previous Cutting Edge Debates
Cannibalism
(Posted August 7, 1998 · Issue 36)
Science Funding
moderated by Donna Crane (Posted June 26, 1998  ·   Issue 33)
Medical Use of Marijuana
moderated by Rik Musty (Posted May 15, 1998  ·   Issue 30)
Career Changes in Science
moderated by Amy Fluet (Posted March 23, 1998  ·   Issue 27)
Model Systems
moderated by Jessica Bolker (Posted January 30, 1998  ·   Issue 24)
Neurodegenerative Diseases
moderated by Donald Price (Posted December 5, 1997  ·   Issue 21)
Shedding Light on Melatonin
moderated by Larry Morin (Posted October 17, 1997  ·   Issue 18)
The Origin of Life
moderated by Michael Meyer (Posted September 5, 1997  ·   Issue 15)
Optimum Mutation Rates in Evolution and Disease
moderated by Bryn Bridges (Posted July 25, 1997  ·   Issue 13)
Models of Immunologic Tolerance
moderated by Kenneth F. Schaffner (Posted June 27, 1997  ·   Issue 11)
Science and Ethics of Mammalian Cloning
moderated by Jon Gordon (Posted May 16, 1997  ·   Issue 8)
Making Sense of Antisense
moderated by C.A. Stein (Posted April 23, 1997  ·   Issue 6)
Academic Tenure: Is It Necessary?
moderated by William Tucker (Posted March 5, 1997  ·   Issue 4)
Do Orphan Receptors Have Ligands?
moderated by Mitch Lazar (Posted February 20, 1997   ·   Issue 2)
The Origin and Evolution of Introns
moderated by Russ Doolittle (Posted February 1, 1997  ·   Issue 1)