BOOK REVIEW

Book Review

Darwin's Radio

[review] [excerpt] [endlinks] [purchase]

by Greg Bear

Reviewed by Jim Kling

Ballantine Books, 2000

Posted June 8, 2001 · Issue 104


Review

If Star Trek, with its impossible physics and English-speaking aliens, is considered by many to be the center of the science fiction universe, hard science fiction is its polar opposite. Hard science fiction explores the limits of known science, sometimes bending but never violating the accepted laws of nature.

Darwin's Radio is more about science than fiction.

Occasionally there appear works of hard science fiction that seem more about science than about fiction. Greg Bear has penned many such novels over the years, including a whole book about unraveling the geology of a far-off planet. His latest novel, Darwin's Radio, which in April 2001 won the Science Fiction Writers of America's prestigious Nebula Award for best novel, is the latest in this genre.

In it, Bear posits a molecular mechanism behind punctuated equilibrium, the theory that holds that evolution goes through long periods of relative stasis, followed by bursts of speciation and then more long silences. The theory explains otherwise puzzling gaps in the fossil record.

It begins with a surprising addition to human paleontology.

This book opens with a particularly surprising addition to human paleontology. High in the Italian Alps, discredited anthropologist (and maverick researcher) Mitch Rafelson is led by a couple of treasure-seeking acquaintances to a frozen cave. There he finds the well-preserved remains of a pair of Neanderthals, an adult male and an adult female. The real surprise, however, lies nearby in a bundle of furs: It is an infant - an anatomically modern infant.

In the next chapter, we are whisked off to the Republic of Georgia, where microbiologist and virologist Kaye Lang is sampling sewage treatment facilities to find new examples of bacteriophages, the viruses that infect bacteria. During her stay, a United Nations peacekeeping force asks her to examine a recently discovered mass grave. Many of the bodies are those of women, and almost all were pregnant.

Ancient endogenous retroviruses get expressed.

Lang and Rafelson independently return to the United States, and soon discover that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has been chasing down a new virus that infects only pregnant women. It turns out to be a reactivation of an endogenous retrovirus - one of those ancient viruses that we appear to be hauling around in our DNA, but that never gets expressed. In Bear's story, they do. And they cause pregnant women to miscarry. But very soon after the miscarriage, the mothers are pregnant again - whether or not they've been sexually active.

The CDC - as well as the increasingly panicked public - sees a horrific viral disease that seems bent on destroying an entire human generation, and many women begin to refuse any physical contact with men. The CDC responds with an attempt to develop a vaccine, and Lang joins the effort because she was the first to document the full sequence of an endogenous retrovirus. She was also the first to hypothesize that they have the potential to be expressed.

Could the virus have anything to do with the Neanderthals?

Rafelson hears about the virus and begins to wonder if it could have anything to do with the sad little frozen family he discovered in the Italian Alps. He had secretly taken tissue samples from the bodies, and now has them analyzed for the presence of the virus. The analyses come up positive, and very soon after that he is introduced to Kaye Lang.

The press calls the disease Herod's flu, after the first-century B.C.E. Roman-appointed "King of the Jews," who, according to one biblical account, ordered the slaughter of all newborns in Bethlehem in order to thwart the prophecy of the coming messiah. As the novel progresses, Herod's flu gains momentum and social order deteriorates. Rafelson and Lang - who have by this time become lovers - realize that the virus is an evolutionary engineer. Cellular stresses produced by a changing environment induce the expression of the virus. It begins to mine the so-called junk DNA that exists throughout the human genome, producing new combinations of genes in the second fetus to create a new kind of baby, one that is perhaps better adapted to the changing environment.

What is human evolution's next phase?

It is here that the science begins to tail off and the real story begins, as Kaye and Mitch start to contemplate what the next phase of human evolution might be.

For a book with such an entrenched scientific theme, Bear does an excellent job of developing his characters. He gives them depth, even if his descriptions sometimes suggest he is scouring the English language for the most explicit adjectives he can find.

Bear develops his characters well.

The novel explores the reactions of scientists and lay people in the face of a looming evolutionary change and provides an interesting look at two scientific minds that are naturally curious about the genetic innovation that may very well render them and their kind physically obsolete.

The story has a feeling of inevitability to it - once you are about a quarter to half of the way through it, you have a general sense of how it will end. But it is still possible to enjoy the characters' reactions to the impending conclusion. That is the real story.

Darwin's Radio reveals something about human nature.

In Darwin's Radio, Bear achieves one of the most important functions of science fiction: He explores human reactions and adaptations to an unforeseen circumstance, and in doing so he reveals something about human nature. You can't do that with other fiction genres, and at its best, this is what science fiction offers us. Few do it as well as Bear has.

Jim Kling writes in Washington State about science and the environment. His work has appeared in Science, Nature Biotechnology, The Scientist, Scientific American, and Popular Science magazine's Web site.

Excerpt

Tilde squeezed so low her face was on the floor beside the bundle. She gripped one end of the fur with two fingers and slowly turned it around. Mitch's throat seized with anguish.

"Shine a light," she demanded.

Mitch did so. Franco aimed his torch as well.

"It's a doll," Tilde said.

From the top of the bundle appeared a small face, like a dark and wrinkled apple, with two tiny sunken black eyes.

"No," Mitch said. "It's a baby."


You may purchase this book (430 pp., hardcover) directly from:



Tell us what you think.
FeedbackFeedback

Do you want your book reviewed by HMS Beagle?


Endlinks

The Opener of the Way - in the course of a wide-ranging interview, Bear says, in reference to the origin of Darwin's Radio, "I've never quite believed the modern synthesis of Darwinian evolution . . . ."

Publisher's Page - Random House/Del Rey promotion page featuring a description of Darwin's Radio, an extensive excerpt, reader reviews, an interview with Bear, and a collection of websites relevant to the book.

BookBrowser Review - an informative and laudatory review of Darwin's Radio.

Institute of Human Origins - a multidisciplinary research organization devoted to fossil evidence for human evolution, directed by Donald C. Johanson, discoverer of the hominid skeleton "Lucy."

Human Endogenous Retroviruses: Nature, Occurrence, and Clinical Implications in Human Disease - an overview in Clinical Microbiological Reviews examines the evidence for their pathological impact (full article available in PDF).


Previous Book Reviews

In the Wake of the Plague: The Black Death and the World It Made
by Jonathan Wells; reviewed by Jonathan Beard
(Posted May 25, 2001 · Issue 103)
The Quest for Immortality: Science at the Frontiers of Aging
by S. Jay Olshansky and Bruce A. Carnes; reviewed by Ed Voves
(Posted May 11, 2001 · Issue 102)
Rocks of Ages: Science and Religion in the Fullness of Life
by Stephen Jay Gould; reviewed by Druin Burch
(Posted April 27, 2001 · Issue 101)
Tomorrow's Cures Today? How to Reform the Health Research System
by Donald R. Forsdyke; reviewed by Charles C. Ouimet
(Posted April 13, 2001 · Issue 100)
Scientific Integrity: An Introductory Text with Cases
by Francis L. Macrina; reviewed by Tim Atkinson
(Posted March 30, 2001 · Issue 99)
Victorian Sensation: The Extraordinary Publication, Reception, and Secret
Authorship of Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation
by James A. Secord; reviewed by Ed Voves
(Posted March 16, 2001 · Issue 98)

more